Strategy Faces Potential Index Exclusion Crisis

A critical decision looms for the company formerly known as MicroStrategy, now confronting what may represent the most significant challenge since its transformation into a Bitcoin-focused treasury vehicle. Market strategists at JPMorgan have issued warnings about potential removal from major stock indices—a development that could trigger devastating consequences for investors. The pivotal determination arrives on January 15th, with substantial capital flows hanging in the balance.

The Disappearing Premium and Broken Model

Strategy’s investment approach previously relied on a straightforward yet effective mechanism: raise capital, purchase Bitcoin, anticipate appreciation, then issue additional shares or bonds to repeat the cycle. This self-reinforcing system, often described as a “Bitcoin flywheel,” functioned successfully while the company’s shares traded at a substantial premium to their net asset value.

That premium has now evaporated. Strategy currently trades nearly exactly at the value of its 649,870 Bitcoin holdings, which were acquired at an average price of $74,433 per coin. Further equity issuance under these conditions would result in significant dilution rather than fueling the company’s expansion model.

Bitcoin itself has retreated substantially from its October peaks, pulling Strategy shares downward in correlation. The relationship between the cryptocurrency and the stock has become nearly absolute, with one crucial distinction: Strategy’s equity is declining at a faster pace than the digital asset it mirrors.

$11.6 Billion in Potential Selling Pressure

The scale of potential market impact is staggering. JPMorgan analysts quantify the immediate risk at $2.8 billion in forced selling by index-tracking funds. Should other major index providers implement similar exclusion policies, the total capital outflow threat escalates to approximately $8.8 billion.

The catalyst for this potential upheaval stems from MSCI’s consideration of new regulations that could exclude companies holding digital assets exceeding 50% of their total assets. Through aggressive Bitcoin accumulation, Strategy has far surpassed this threshold, placing the company in regulatory crosshairs with potentially dramatic implications.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Strategy?

Market performance already reflects these concerns. Strategy shares have collapsed over 40% in just one month, establishing new 52-week lows. Passive fund managers controlling approximately $9 billion in holdings face mounting pressure to divest.

Identity Crisis Following Rebranding Effort

The company’s August 2025 transition from MicroStrategy to Strategy was intended to signal a new beginning. Instead, markets increasingly perceive the organization not as a software enterprise but exclusively as a leveraged Bitcoin proxy.

The $500 million corporate analysis software business no longer factors meaningfully into valuation discussions. Investor attention focuses singularly on the Bitcoin position—and what happens if Strategy faces forced liquidation scenarios.

January 15th: A Binary Outcome

MSCI confronts a clear threshold question: whether companies with digital asset exposure exceeding 50% should remain eligible for traditional equity benchmarks. Strategy operates far beyond this proposed boundary, making its inclusion status increasingly tenuous.

The January 15th decision presents a binary outcome: either Strategy maintains access to institutional capital through index funds, or the company faces relegation to niche investment vehicle status. The latter scenario would trigger mechanical selling by passive funds, creating potentially irreversible momentum.

The coming 60 days will demonstrate whether innovative treasury approaches incorporating digital assets can coexist with established index methodologies. For Strategy shareholders, the stakes couldn’t be higher.