Primerica Shares Face Market Pressure Despite Strong Quarterly Performance

Primerica’s stock has been experiencing notable downward momentum in recent trading sessions, with investors showing mixed reactions to the company’s latest developments. During yesterday’s session, shares closed at $271.50, marking a 1.23% decline from the previous day’s closing price of $274.90. Trading activity remained relatively subdued with 171,376 shares changing hands, while the price fluctuated between $271.47 and $278.13 throughout the day.

Strong Fundamentals Contrast With Market Sentiment

Despite the current bearish trend, Primerica’s latest quarterly results demonstrate robust financial health. The company significantly outperformed analyst expectations across key metrics:

• Q2 2025 EPS: $5.46 (versus $5.18 expected)
• Revenue growth: 3% to $796.02 million
• Q1 2025: Adjusted net operating income increased 14% to $168 million

The term life insurance division showed particular strength, placing 86,415 new policies representing $28 billion in coverage. Even more impressive was the performance of Investment and Savings Products, where sales surged 28% to $3.6 billion. Net flows in this segment nearly tripled, reaching $839 million.

Management has provided optimistic guidance for full-year 2025, projecting mid to high single-digit growth for ISP sales and approximately 5% growth in term life premiums. Despite these strong fundamentals and forward-looking projections, the market’s current valuation approach appears punishing, with shares trading at a P/E ratio of just 3.8.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Primerica?

Consumer Debt Trends Raise Concerns

Recent research published by Primerica reveals troubling patterns in consumer financial behavior. The study indicates that 39% of middle-income American households increased their credit card usage in June—representing an 11 percentage point increase since the beginning of the year. Only 32% of surveyed consumers now pay their credit card balance in full each month, compared to 38% two years ago.

Average credit card debt per borrower has climbed significantly, reaching $6,473 in Q2 2025. This figure represents a 22.8% increase compared to the same period in 2022, highlighting growing financial pressure on consumers.

Parallel research examining Canadian attitudes toward financial technology reveals a preference for traditional services among middle-income earners. A majority of Canadian respondents expressed skepticism toward AI-powered financial advisory tools, indicating a continued preference for conventional advisory relationships.